Two 2006 IO Syrahs

Nielson Vineyard; 14.8% ABV
Upper Bench; 14.8% ABV
both from Santa Maria Valley, CA
$6 each at the Oakland, CA, store on 7 Oct

Seedboy alerted us to these wines by writing on 6 October (slightly edited):

New wines in Oakland.  Both of these wines have good fruit. Pushed ripeness a bit but still good balance between the acid and other flavors. They both have a lot of the peppery quality you’d expect from the cool climate Syrahs they are, but more fruit than most northern Rhone wines. The Upper Bench has more stuffing and is more complex.  For tonight the Nielson is really lovely.  You can’t go wrong with these, especially at $5.99 a bottle.

2006_IO_Syrah_NielsonVnydBased on this recommendation, I started with the Nielsen Vineyard and was not disappointed.  Although delicious right away, it became more delicate and balanced after about an hour in a decanter.  The fruit was very ripe, with a lightly syrupy character, showing flavors of blackberry, blueberry, purple grape, balanced by a roasted or charred character that was close to a bitter herbal component, and nice acid of black and red currants and darker cranberry.  It’s not all that well delineated or elegant, but it’s a very tasty CA Syrah.



2006_IO_Syrah_UpperBenchThe Upper Bench is immediately noticeable as more complex and far more elegant than the Nielson.  After about 70 minutes of air, it presents a similar lightly syrupy character, but with flavors of blackberry, blueberry, dark red cherry, vanilla, violets, and a similar (but not as strong) lightly charred edge.  The Nielson is tasty, but the Upper Bench is terrific.  Both good buys.


7 thoughts on “Two 2006 IO Syrahs

  1. seedboy

    Opened a bottle of the Upper Bench last night. I hope I have more of this because it was absolutely delicious, maybe even better than when first purchased. Last sip was the best.

      1. seedboy

        Yep. On this one only the very end was saturated, so it was a great seal. I know I have at least 3 of the 2006 Grenache left.

  2. GOWineLover

    Agreed wholeheartedly. The Upper Bench is the superior of the two and is much better integrated overall almost in every way. It’s nice and ripe but not overblown. Highly recommended and one of the fewer and fewer recent deals that used to be so common. Pleasant Hill and Concord have had plenty the last few days. If you’re a big Syrah lover but like something just slightly more dialed back and elegant, this is for you. Fantastic value at $5.99.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s